Shocking, Buried UK Government Report: Disposable Diapers are Better for the Environment Than Cloth Nappies
It is a commonly held belief amongst green parents that cloth diapers, or nappies as they are called across the pond, are better for the environment than disposable ones. We’ve written about the benefits of cloth diapers multiple times, and I have even shared my eco-guilt over using Seventh Generation disposables. A new UK government report finds exactly the opposite: disposable diapers are better for the environment.
This finding is shocking! Government ministers couldn’t believe it either and actually buried the report, because they were embarrassed by the findings. According to the Times Online:
The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) has instructed civil servants not to publicise the conclusions of the £50,000 nappy research project and to adopt a “defensive” stance towards its conclusions.
The report found that using washable nappies, hailed by councils throughout Britain as a key way of saving the planet, have a higher carbon footprint than their disposable equivalents unless parents adopt an extreme approach to laundering them.
To reduce the impact of cloth nappies on climate change parents would have to hang wet nappies out to dry all year round, keep them for years for use on younger children, and make sure the water in their washing machines does not exceed 60C.
- » See also: Disney Admits Baby Einstein Does NOT Increase Intelligence
- » Get Eco Child’s Play by RSS or sign up by email.
For my family, cloth diapers were the best choice. I did use the same diapers and covers on two children for a total of six years of diapering. I only wash in cold water, and I live off-the-grid using renewable hydro power. Our only downfall is that I did place them in the dryer, which runs on propane, to further sanitize them and to make them softer for my children’s little bums.
I think what can be learned from this report is that no matter what choice we make when it comes to diapering our children, we need to consider what we do after we make that choice. The kind of disposable diaper chosen or the method of laundering a cloth diaper has a significant impact on the environment.
The report found that while disposable nappies used over 2½ years would have a global warming impact of 550kg of CO2 reusable nappies produced 570kg of CO2 on average. But if parents used tumble dryers and washed the reusable nappies at 90C, the impact could spiral to . 993kg of CO2 A Defra spokesman said the government was shelving plans for future research on nappies.
I don’t think the report considered the impact on landfills of disposable diapers, and I think that further research needs to be done. I can’t embrace these findings, as there are many factors that were not considered. What about diaper services that reuse the same cloth diapers many times for many families? I don’t know any families that just dispose of their cloth diapers when their children have completed their toilet learning. If they are still in good shape, they are passed on to other families. If they are stained and falling apart, they are used as rags. I still think using cloth diapers was the best choice for my children’s health and the environment despite this report.
Image: Ecoscraps
Thanks for the thought-provoking story. It does show two things, in my opinion: 1) having children does add to the load on the planet, no matter what we do, and 2) some studies are of limited value. I make the second statement because the study seems to have ignored the many, many steps needed to make the plastics in the disposable diapers, as well as landfill space, methane output, and ultimately the clean up of all disposable plastics.
I agree that they must have overlooked the landfill issues. The carbon is only a part of the issue overall, but so many people pay attention to just that fragment.
I’ve read that report - it was buried for a reason. Not only was it bad science but it made a lot of assumptions that are simply not true. Like you mentioned, cloth diapers get reused for up to five children. The water used to wash cloth diapers is about the same as the amount used by the same number of kids to flush a toilet - so a child in toilet training uses the same amount of water as a child in diapers. It also ignores much of the steps required to produce and transport disposables. I actually wrote a blog about it, but yes, you are right to question and ultimately dismiss this study. It wasn’t out of embarrassment for the results - but for the way they were obtained and, therefore, their inaccuracy.
I have to say that disregarding the landfill aspect seems to miss much of the point. Plus, that means disregarding the biodegradability questions.
Carbon footprint is only one aspect, not the whole story, of sound environmental choices.
What an interesting topic here, as I think they failed to research the manufacturing of disposables and the impact on the landfills. Great topic!
True… But perhaps it is acceptable to say that the difference in impact is negligible enough that there are far better ways to spend your efforts on a greener future.
@ Amber, thank you for commenting! I just read your excellent post. Great writing and explanation. I seriously doubt that the original study looked at landfill usage, leaking landfills, production of plastics, retrieval of petroleum to manufacture plastics… In short, there’s no story here.
I don’t think I believe this report at all. I’m sure the footprint required to make the disposable diapers wasn’t included, as well as certain other factors.
Somewhat unrelated, what about the environmental/health effects of the fecal matter in landfills? I’m pretty sure the majority of people using disposables don’t flush what needs flushing (and is recommended to be flushed on the outer packaging of disposables). Yucky. I still like the GDiaper concept. I wish a couple brands would latch on to that idea and make them cheaper!
Wow! I’m surprised by the report but not by the burying of the report. Thanks for this. Again, wow!
Of course they fail to talk about all the nasty chemicals in those diapers… some of the same chemicals that have been removed from feminine hygiene products for safety concerns. That’s just not something I want on my baby’s bum!
I say, opt for ORGANIC cotton nappies (one size so you don’t have to buy several sets) with woolies for covers. Skip the water soak (poses drowning risk anyway), wash on warm not hot, add hydrogen peroxide to the wash for extra whitening power, rinse with vinegar to help soften, hang dry or tumble for the minimum time needed. Diapers should only add a load a week.
I’m not buying it that the use of cloth is actually worse for the environment. Maybe if we buy the fancy diapering options (in non organic cotton) which require a whole new set every couple of months, if we wash on the hottest cycle possible (with an extra rinse), use chemical laden detergents and chlorine bleach and tumble dry for an excessive length of time.
And as Elizabeth pointed out… those diapers lurking in our landfills are full of bacteria and viruses from bundled up baby poo. That is UNTREATED sewage that is leaking back into the water supply. I’d much rather flush it into a sewer system.
We’ll stick with cloth… and the occasional gDiaper for long trips!