Do Natural Dishwasher Detergents Actually Work?
Over the last couple of months, dish washing in our house has become an experiment of sorts. One of the last household items to go natural in our home was our dishwasher detergent. I was having difficulty finding one that REALLY worked. And you, Dear Reader, gets to benefit from my trial (and error).
The Round-Up:
Palmolive Eco+ - liquid in lemon splash
Planet - powder
Seventh Generation- powder and liquid
Method- Smarty Dish Detergent tabs in pink grapefruit (20 count unwrapped in tub)
Ecover-tabs (25 count individually wrapped in clear plastic)
- » See also: EWG Gives School Cleaning Supplies Their Report Cards (and it ain’t pretty)
- » Get Eco Child’s Play by RSS or sign up by email.
Let me start by saying, I’m not a fan of powder dishwasher detergent and avoid it. My favorite are tabs because I know the right amount is being used and there is no mess. Liquid falls in the middle.
The Palmolive Eco+ ($2.99 at Fred Meyer/Kroger’s) is basically a greenwashed product. The only ecological benefit of these dishwasher detergent is that it is free of phosphates. IMO, it didn’t clean nearly as well as I expected. This will not be used in our home in the future.
I didn’t like the Planet ($4.59 at Fred Meyer/Kroger’s) powder AT ALL. My dishes came out with residue and most had to be rewashed. It was a trying few weeks. I will not use Planet again.
The Ecover ($3.99 at Whole Foods) tablets worked okay. The tablets had a tendency to crumble somewhat when taken out of their wrap. They would fall in a decent cleaning range, but definitely far from what I experienced with traditional cleaners. While the outer package is cardboard and therefore recyclable, each tablet is individually wrapped. While the wrappers are said to be recyclable, they aren’t in my area and I suspect in most areas. I would use these tabs again if my number one or two choices weren’t available.
My favorites are the Method tabs and Seventh Generation Liquid. Both these products provided a great clean with no noticeable difference from traditional cleaners.
As for what they are made of, Method’s website proclaims “Instead of the nasty phosphates and bleach that make up conventional dishwasher detergent, smarty dish is made from super effective ingredients so green that one of them won a presidential green chemistry award (yes, that really is an award). The blend of mineral cleaning salts, anti-spotting agents and enzymes give smarty dish some serious kick, while the biodegradable and non-toxic ingredients mean no harmful residues or fumes to worry about in your home… and happy fish after they rinse down the drain. The formula is DfE-recognized, with packaging made from 25% recycled plastic. What’s more, smarty dish is specially formulated to be effective yet gentle on glass and flatware to prevent etching.”
Seventh Generation claims, “Non-toxic, No Chlorine bleach or phosphates, No dyes, No NTA or EDTA, Safe for septic & greywater systems, Not tested on animals, Kosher certified.”
The Method ($4.99 at Target) tablets come in a small, squarish, plastic container with a snap close lid. The container is made from 25% recycled plastic and I find it a useful tub to reuse around the house. I would love to see refill packages that use less material since we have no need for a new plastic container every month. Smarty Dish is available in (YUMMY) pink grapefruit and go naked (sans perfume and color). The tablets kept their shape well, without crumble. There was little residue left in the container once the tabs were used.
The Seventh Generation ($4.59 at Fred Meyer/Kroger’s) liquid comes in the traditional plastic squeeze bottle with snap cap. Once emptied the bottle can be rinsed and sent out with recycling (at least in my area, check with your local curbside pick up). I have to monitor the kids on their dish nights to be sure they don’t overuse the liquid cleanser.
[...] detergents and it was really becoming a drudgery. Then I found an extremely helpful review by Eco Child’s Play. They confirmed my experience with the Planet and Ecover brands, which was only [...]
[...] supplies. That isn’t necessary for a tidy home, though I do use a few products (hand soap, dishwasher tabs, and the [...]
I’m still really happy with the Bright Green Safeway brand eco dishwasher powder. There is no plastic packaging to add to the landfill like with tablets. I don’t put chunks of food in the dishwasher, so I don’t know about how it compares cleaning crud off. And rinsing off your dishes lets you use the shortest cycle, saving you money.
I tried the Bright Green sold in Safeway. It left large uneven spots. It looks like dishes and glasses were etched. Spots Look real bad and can not be easily removed even by scrubbing. I will never use it again.
I just tried Bright Green- in my opinion, it is the WORST I have ever tried. Especially on my flatware- there’s a horrible film that is almost impossible to get off. The rest of the dishes look filmy and spotty and horrible- worse than when I put them in. I think the plastic of my favorite vegetable peeler is ruined- in appearance anyway. I tried washing it w/ regular dish soap (hand wash kind) and it didn’t improve. I tried adding baking soda to the next load, thinking it might help the detergent out w/ our hard water- no difference. I can’t bring myself to throw it away, so I think I’ll buy some other detergent and just add a tiny bit of the Bright Green until it is gone.
[...] Dishwasher Maintenance”;We know to only run the dishwasher when we have a full load. We also know that there are lots of great options for Earth-friendly dishwashing detergents. What we don’t always think about though, is good old maintenance. Nothing wastes water like [...]
Thank you so much for your post…
I totally disagree on the 7th Generation Liquid, tho. I have a brand new dishwasher which cleans like a DREAM with those cascade packets. But I started experimenting because I can’t stand thinking I’m eating all that residue.
Anyway, 7th Gen liquid leaves a film on all my glassware (I have glass plates and cups). It’s terrible. Doesn’t remove lipstick marks either (GROSS!) even when on a heavy wash cycle which doesn’t exactly help me save water.
Also tried the Trader Joe’s liquid and that’s even worse. Total, complete crap.
Has anyone had a bunch of residue on their dishes after using the Method dishwashing tablets in grapefruit? I used them a few times and the third time my dishes came out looking all white, my kids plastic cups looked ruined, major residue. I have never had a problem like this with other conventional tablets.
It is horrible that products are being marketed as “ECO” friendly but still has bleach and other harmful chemicals in it!! (AND they don’t even WORK)
I’m glad i found a company that actually provides great cleaning and personal care products with no chemicals or phosphates!
We try very hard (too hard) to use green cleaning products, but some of them just don’t cut it. We’ve been switching back and forth between plain old Cascade dishwasher detergent (which works great but kills the environment) and the safeway-brand Bright Green Dishwasher Gel Detergent. And every time we try Bright Green, the dishes come out dirty. We are through… we’ve tried and tried and tried… but they need to go back to the drawing board. And we hope they do. But, let’s face it, a lot of these ‘green’ products just don’t get your stuff clean. These companies need to hold themselves to significantly higher standards of quality, and not just market products that half-work, if they want to retain customers. (And it kills me to say this… I am an obsessed greenie… but I am so fed up!!!)