What Do Girls Really Think of Barbie?

We all have our opinions about Barbie!  Some people adore this icon of American toys; some people blame the doll for distorting our perception of the ideal beauty resulting in 32,000 boob jobs a month.

 We know Barbie is guilty of greenwashing and that she is toxic, but what do the little girls that play with her really think?

Discovery News reports:

Surprisingly little research has been done specifically on girls’ opinions of Barbie dolls; indeed, researchers Tara Kuther and Erin McDonald note in their article “Early Adolescents’ Experiences with, and Views of, Barbie” (Adolescence, Vol. 39, No. 153) that “the extant literature about Barbie dolls tends to be opinionated and based on essays and popular media articles” instead of science or evidence-based research…

The handful of research studies that have been done hold some surprising results. For example, the Kuther and McDonald study mentioned above concluded that “most notably girls reported ambivalence toward Barbie dolls.”

In 2005 a team of British researchers from the University of Bath “found that many 7- to 11-year-old girls hate the doll so much that they physically attack it. … Barbie is hated because she is ‘babyish,’ ‘unfashionable,’ ‘plastic,’ has multiple selves and because she is a feminine icon.”

Not only do many of the girls dislike Barbie, they actively mutilate and torture their dolls. According to lead researcher Agnes Nairn, “the girls we spoke to see Barbie torture as a legitimate play activity. … The types of mutilation are varied and creative, and range from removing the hair to decapitation, burning, breaking, and even microwaving.”

Not that I condone violence against plastic dolls, but the above descriptions of mutilations made me laugh.

The Discovery article goes on to say that Barbie does not influence our ideas of a perfect human body, “Nor is there good evidence that girls (or women) view the doll as a physical role model.”  This statement I disagree with, especially when the author admits, “Surprisingly little research has been done.”

Advertising and marketing is effective because it sways public opinion about what we want, need, etc.  For example, of tobacco ads using cartoon characters did not affect teen smoking, why were they banned?  I feel a similar connection can be made between playing with Barbies as a young child and the desire to be blonde and buxom.  When Barbie paraphernalia is includes the word “dream” (dream house, dream car, etc.), isn’t meant to influence you  as to what you should aspire to acquire in life?  Isn’t the whole point of the career-inspired Barbies to influence young girls into believing any career is possible?

Image:  LicenseAttribution Some rights reserved by puuikibeach

Enhanced by Zemanta

Comments

  1. Erinne says:

    I read in a book whose title I don’t remember about how girls play with barbies when they are very little and then as they grow, the “violence” against barbie is part of how they pull away from early childhood and assert themselves as emerging young women.

  2. Seeing the burned Barbie doll I really felt uncomfortable, no matter how a person dislike the doll , one should not do such a rough thing to it.

  3. In my Kindle ebook for middle-grade readers, White Rabbit Time by Lynda, an imaginative young girl uses her fashion dolls to exercise her needs for creativity and empowerment. Check it out at http://www.Amazon.com or on my author’s page at https://www.amazon.com/author/ebooksbylynda .

  4. Sarah Elizabeth Snider says:

    I’d like to take a paddle and bust these children’s rear ends. There are little girls in Joplin, Missouri who lost everything last May and would give anything for a Barbie to hug and play with, and here these little brats are wrecking their playthings. Didn’t their parents teach them to appreciate what they received? If they hate Barbie so much then why don’t they donate their dolls to kids who are less fortunate? That way nothing gets thrown away, nothing gets destroyed, deprived little kids get something to play with, and the older girls have their unwanted Barbies out of their hair. And neither set of parents has to pay another dime. Everyone wins.